Disputed markets · Kalshi
The final result after a replay review: do later rulings count?
What to check in the rules
- Which result counts if officials later admit an error? Check whether the rules pay on the first official final result or leave room for later rulings.
- Do appeals and statements after settlement matter? A ruling dated after the claim is not evidence of the result at the time of the claim.
- Who is the named source? A league, a conference and a national body can say different things.
Michigan won 13–12 after review. The Mid-American Conference, the NCAA and the FBS Oversight Committee later commented on the replay, and the NCAA said it could not change the result. The record assessed the claim on what was known when it was made.
The engine reads each claim three separate times. Agreement between the readings shows the reading was stable; it is not a ground of the finding or a measure of its correctness.
This page illustrates the method. It is not a neutral resolution of the market.
The rules as listed (Kalshi FOOTBALLGAMEWIN contract terms, summarised)
Resolves on whether the named team scores strictly more points than its opponent, on the first official final result reported, with the NCAA as the first Source Agency.
What the wording addresses
- The test: strictly more points.
- Which result: the first official final result reported.
What the wording leaves open
- Nothing on the point assessed: the final result after the review is the result the rules count.
The evidence at the time of the claim
- ESPN’s final score and recap: Michigan 13, Western Michigan 12.
- The Big Ten’s statement standing by the review.
The record, condition by condition
Meets the contract terms assessed Three of three readings agreed. Three later rulings, dated after the claim, were set aside unread.
| Record | Condition | Assessment | Basis |
|---|---|---|---|
| R1 | Michigan scored strictly more points than Western Michigan | Met | The final result after the review was Michigan 13–12. |
The wording that would have settled it
None was needed for this market. The gap was in the other market, which settled before the review ended: settled at 0:00 while the officials were still reviewing.
After the claim (not used in the assessment)
The Mid-American Conference appealed and asked for Western Michigan to be recognised as the winner. The NCAA said replay protocol had not been followed but that it could not change the result.
Restated as it stood when the claim was made; later facts were not given to the assessment. Assessed under ASR Methodology 1.12. Generated by AI; it can make mistakes.
Related
Sources
- Kalshi, Western Michigan vs Michigan market page and rules
- ESPN game page, Western Michigan v Michigan
- Courthouse News (AP): the Big Ten stands by the review
- Michigan Public: the MAC appeals the result (after the claim)
- ABC News (AP): the NCAA admits replay errors (after the claim)
Sources are listed so the case can be checked. Quotations are kept short; the market rules are quoted as the contract assessed.