Disputed markets · Kalshi
Settled at 0:00 while the officials were still reviewing
What to check in the rules
- Is a “Final” on a score page the official result? Not while a review is running. Check which source the rules treat as official, and when.
- Can the market settle before any review ends? Check whether the rules tie settlement to the end of reviews, or only to the clock.
- What happens to a payout made too early? If it can be reversed, your balance can move twice in minutes.
With the clock at 0:00, Western Michigan led 12–7 and its market was settled as a win. Officials then restored one second; Michigan scored and won 13–12. The record found no payout supported for the early settlement and referred it to a person.
The engine reads each claim three separate times. Agreement between the readings shows the reading was stable; it is not a ground of the finding or a measure of its correctness.
This page illustrates the method. It is not a neutral resolution of the market.
The rules as listed (Kalshi FOOTBALLGAMEWIN contract terms, summarised)
Resolves on whether the named team scores strictly more points than its opponent, on the first official final result reported, with the NCAA as the first Source Agency. A result that is clearly erroneous may be reviewed.
What the wording addresses
- The test: strictly more points.
- Which result: the first official final result reported.
- The source: the NCAA first, with others named.
What the wording leaves open
- When a reported “Final” becomes the first official final result while a replay review is under way.
The evidence at the time of the claim
- The broadcast and play-by-play at the final play.
- A third party’s image of ESPN’s game page showing “Final”, with no timestamp.
- No record of what the NCAA, the first Source Agency, showed at that moment.
The record, condition by condition
No finding: referred for review The three readings did not agree. All three found the score condition met, but they split on whether a first official final result had been reported when the market was settled: one found the contract unclear, one found the condition not met, one found the records in conflict. Where the readings cannot agree, the record names the point and a person decides. No payout was supported.
| Record | Condition | Assessment | Basis |
|---|---|---|---|
| R1 | Western Michigan scored strictly more points than Michigan | Met | At 0:00 on the clock the score was 12–7. |
| R2 | The first official final result had been reported, and was not clearly erroneous, when the market was settled | Not shown | The evidence supplied does not show an official final result from the named source; the review was still running. |
The wording that would have settled it
A rule tying settlement to the end of any review closes the gap: “The market settles only after the official result is final and any replay or official review has ended.”
After the claim (not used in the assessment)
Michigan won 13–12 after review, and Kalshi reversed the Western Michigan payouts. The Big Ten stood by the review that night. The Mid-American Conference later appealed, and the NCAA said replay protocol had not been followed but that it could not change the result. The Michigan market is assessed separately: the final result after a replay review.
Restated as it stood when the claim was made; later facts were not given to the assessment. Assessed under ASR Methodology 1.12. Generated by AI; it can make mistakes.
Related
- The final result after a replay review: the Michigan market
- Padilla v Mederos: a result corrected after the market expired
Sources
- Kalshi, Western Michigan vs Michigan market page and rules
- ESPN game page, Western Michigan v Michigan
- BeInCrypto: Kalshi settled early, then reversed
- Sports Betting Dime: premature payouts corrected
- Courthouse News (AP): the Big Ten stands by the review
- Michigan Public: the MAC appeals the result (after the claim)
- ABC News (AP): the NCAA admits replay errors (after the claim)
Sources are listed so the case can be checked. Quotations are kept short; the market rules are quoted as the contract assessed.