What can go wrong when a prediction market resolves?
In short: most disputes start in the wording, not in the event. A market can be settled exactly as written and still surprise traders, because the title said one thing and the rules said another. Seven points in the rules account for most of these surprises. Each one below links to a real market where it happened.
Seven points to check in a market's rules
- The exact trigger. “Announced”, “agreed”, “appointed”, “banned” and “completed” are different events. Find the verb the rules use, and whether they define it.
Seen in: Ukraine: does “agreed” mean signed? · TikTok: does “banned” mean enforced? · Zelenskyy suit: a word the market never defined - Who confirms it. A named source can be silent, late, or contradict another named source. Check whether the rules say which source prevails.
Seen in: Ukraine: official statements pointing both ways
How often: In all 35 CFTC filings read by the monitor, the payout rule names where the result comes from. - What is excluded. Interim roles, rumours, partial outcomes, a different title. Exclusions decide more markets than inclusions.
Seen in: Kalshi next NVIDIA CEO: interim appointments excluded - Events the rules did not foresee. A reversal, a withdrawn decision, a replay review, a person returning to a role they left. If the rules are silent, someone will have to decide.
Seen in: Western Michigan v Michigan: settled during a replay review · Kalshi next NVIDIA CEO: a return by the former CEO - Timing. Does the deadline apply to the event or to the evidence of it? Can the named source report in time? Which time zone applies, and does “before” include the deadline date?
Seen in: Strategy: a sale inside the window, disclosed the day after · Padilla v Mederos: a result corrected after the market expired - Changes after you trade. Clarifications added after a market opens, or after it closes, can change how it settles. Note the rules’ wording and date when you trade.
Seen in: Strategy: a context note added the day after expiry - Who decides when it is unclear. On Kalshi, the exchange has a review process and can determine payouts. On Polymarket’s international platform, a proposed outcome can be challenged and disputes go to a token-holder vote. Know which applies, and what the fallback rules say.
Seen in: Strategy, Ukraine, Suit and TikTok: all decided by vote
How often: In the fallback rules of the same 35 filings (what happens if the event is cancelled or delayed, the source is silent, or the result is challenged), 81 of 195 provisions (42%) name a source, and 57 of 195 (29%) describe how settlement would be worked out.
“Seen in” links are worked cases: real markets restated as they stood when the claim was made. They are examples, chosen because they were disputed, not a sample, so they show what can happen rather than how often. The “How often” figures come from the settlement-terms monitor, which reads every event-contract filing received by the US Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) in a period: the baseline edition covers 35 filings received from 21 September to 30 October 2026. Those filings come from CFTC-regulated exchanges, not from Polymarket’s international platform. A fallback rule that names no source is not necessarily defective; the monitor reports what each says.
Check the rules of your market
Paste the rules of any event contract and get a reading of what the wording addresses and what it leaves open, at listing or before a resolution is proposed.
This page explains how to read market rules; it is not trading or legal advice. Readings are produced with an automated AI service and can contain mistakes. PNDK Solutions Limited is not a law firm.